Markets Home

Active trader

Hear from active traders about their experience adding CME Group futures and options on futures to their portfolio.

Find a broker

Search our directory for a broker that fits your needs.

CREATE A CMEGROUP.COM ACCOUNT:

MORE FEATURES, MORE INSIGHTS

Get quick access to tools and premium content, or customize a portfolio and set alerts to follow the market.
Market Data Home

Real-time market data

Stream live futures and options market data directly from CME Group.

E-quotes application

Access real-time data, charts, analytics and news from anywhere at anytime.

CME DATAMINE:

THE SOURCE FOR HISTORICAL DATA

Explore historical market data straight from the source to help refine your trading strategies.
Services Home

Uncleared margin rules

Understand how CME Group can help you navigate new initial margin regulatory and reporting requirements.

Calculate margin 

Evaluate your cleared margin requirements using our interactive margin calculator.
Education Home

FX Insights from Macro Hive

Receive exclusive insights on key FX macro themes, volatility trends, and market events through our bi-weekly report.

Create a CMEGroup.com Account: More features, more insights

Get quick access to premium educational content, including expert-led webinars, a real-time trading simulator, and more.
      Course Overview
      • Introduction to STIR Futures
      • Fundamentals and Interest Rate Futures
      • Understanding IMM Price and Date
      • The Link Between Eurodollar Futures Pricing And The Forward Rate Market
      • What is the Eurodollar Settlement Process (cash settled)
      • The Importance of Basis Point Value (BPV)
      • Understanding Convexity Bias
      • What is ICE LIBOR/What is Eurodollar
      • Understanding the FOMC Report
      • Introduction to Fed Fund Futures
      • Introduction to the CME FedWatch Tool
      • What is SOFR
      • Trading SOFR Futures
      • What is SONIA?
      • Trading SONIA Futures
      Understanding STIR Futures
      You completed this course.Get Completion Certificate

      Understanding Convexity Bias

        • Also available in

        • 한국어

      Video not supported!

      To understand the convexity bias, you must understand the parallels between the Eurodollar futures market and the forward rate agreement (FRA) market. Both of these markets are large, liquid and have a vast influence on short-term interest rate pricing.

      FRAs are an over the counter (OTC) bilateral agreement that allows the buyer/seller to notionally borrow/lend a specified amount at a ICE LIBOR-based linked rate over a forward period.

      What is Convexity Bias?

      Convexity bias appears in short-term interest rate instruments because of the payoff differences in the futures market versus the OTC FRA market (aka forward market). 

      For example, as Eurodollar futures (the underlying interest rate for Eurodollar futures) moves up and down, the payoff for the Eurodollar futures contract remains the same. If rates move up one basis point, the futures will change by $25.00 per contract. If rates move down one basis point, futures will also change by $25.00 per contract. Whether you profit or book a loss depends on if you are long or short on the futures.  

      With FRA agreements there is a convex payoff. Increases and decreases in rates produce differing payoffs. Its market value rises more for a given decline in rates than it would for a decline for the same size in the forward rate.

      As rates decrease 10 basis points from 2.00 to 1.90, notice the Eurodollar (ED) futures lose $250,000, but the FRA payoff is 250,062. The same thing happens for an increase in rates. ED futures gain $250,000 but the FRA loses $62.00 less. 

      Remember ED futures move inversely with interest rates.

      The table shows the convexity bias between a position of short 1000 Eurodollar (ED) futures and an offsetting short $1005m 3-month FRA (slightly more than $1000m to compensate for discounting methodology), both instigated at a rate of 2%. 

      • An increase in underlying rates from 2% to 2.10% would result in a credit to the variation margin account of short 1000 ED STIR position of $250,000 and a debit of slightly less than that in the discounted equivalent of $1005m-3M FRA collateral account (assuming zero threshold – zero threshold means every dollar of value change has to be made good.).
      • A decrease in underlying rates of 10 basis points to 1.9% would result in a debit to the variation margin account of a short 1000 ED STIR position of $250,000 and a credit of slightly more than in the $1005m 3-month FRA collateral account (assuming zero threshold). 

      Source:  STIR Futures—Trading Euribor and Eurodollar futures, by Stephen Aikin

      The amount of the convexity is small at the short end of the curve. The example is using a three-month FRA and Eurodollar futures. Further out on the curve the convexity increases and sometimes dramatically.

      Why is Convexity Important?

      Although changes in the market have diminished the convexity phenomenon, fixed income traders have to be aware of the bias because of the effects on larger OTC transactions, like FRAs, that are further out on the yield curve. While the change might only be a few hundred dollars on a short term FRA, the changes in a 5-year FRA could be orders of magnitude higher, costing portfolio managers valuable capital.  

      Still the Eurodollar futures markets and the underlying FRA market closely track each other as spreading and arbitrage opportunities keep them from getting too far out of line.

      What Contributes to Convexity Bias? 

      It is thought that the Convexity bias is due to the following:

      • The way Eurodollar futures are margined versus an FRA instrument
      • The cash flows paid out over the life of a futures contract versus an FRA. Futures are marked-to-market each day by the clearinghouse, while cash flows in an FRA are paid off differently.
      • Volatility in the interest rate markets, generally increasing volatility could cause margin changes.  

      Final Considerations

      Over the years since the financial crisis, the convexity bias has significantly declined.  Since many OTC swaps/FRAs etc. have migrated to central counterparty clearing models such as the exchanges, the margining similarities have contributed to a decline in the convexity bias. 

      Uncleared margin rules also have impacted funding on OTC trading such as swaps and forward rate agreements. Higher funding rates should, in theory, drive such transactions to the exchanges, such as CME Group, where margin benefits and margin offsets can be realized.


      Test your knowledge

      Related Courses
      /content/cmegroup/en/education/courses/understanding-stir-futures/understanding-convexity-bias
      • {{ course.name }}
      Previous Lesson
      Next Lesson
      Course Overview
      Get Completion Certificate
      Previous Lesson Next Lesson
      • YouTube
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      • Instagram
      • Rss

      CME Group is the world's leading and most diverse derivatives marketplace. The company is comprised of four Designated Contract Markets (DCMs). 
      Further information on each exchange's rules and product listings can be found by clicking on the links to CME, CBOT, NYMEX and COMEX.

      © 2021 CME Group Inc. All rights reserved.

      Disclaimer  |  Privacy Policy  |  Cookie Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Data Terms of Use  |  Modern Slavery Act Transparency Statement  |  Report a Security Concern