The Global Rise of Henry Hub Liquidity

  • 7 Dec 2020
  • By Adila McHich
  • Topics: Energy

Henry Hub has long been considered the most important gas market on the planet due to its robust liquidity and benchmark status.

That status has continued to grow in recent years as traders around the world have turned to Henry Hub Natural Gas futures to manage their exposure to gas prices, in part because of the growing influence of US liquified natural gas (LNG) exports on the global market. 

This greater trading interest and the increased exposure created by LNG exports has led to a clear upturn in the trading volume of Henry Hub during European and Asian time zones. LNG traders are particularly active in Henry Hub because of its deep liquidity, which reduces transaction costs, improves the speed of price discovery, and provides clear price formation.

As liquidity in European and Asian trading hours grows, Henry Hub futures can provide a richer picture for global dynamics around the clock, sending price signals on the spreads to the once regionally isolated European, US, and Asian LNG markets.

Increased trading activity

Trading activity in Henry Hub futures has historically been concentrated in regular US trading hours, largely because of the previously largely isolated nature of the US gas market. But with LNG now connecting US markets to the world, the number of transactions executed during Asian and European trading hours has risen for the second year consecutively.

As shown in Chart One, the average transaction volume during European and Asian hours reached a record high of 788,635 and 321,123 contracts, respectively, in Q1 2020. The volume then decreased in Q2 2020 and Q3 2020 ‒ but is still larger when compared to 2019. The new trend suggests that more Europe- and Asia-based LNG traders are relying on Henry Hub as a price reference to either capture any interregional arbitrage opportunity or to hedge a physical position.

Henry Hub Futures Volume by Trading Time Zones1

Source: CME Group

Global LNG trading increased by an estimated 13% in Q1 2020 compared to Q1 2019, then declined from May to June due to the lockdown. Europe accounted for approximately two-thirds of world LNG demand during the first half of the year, even though pipeline base imports contracted from traditional suppliers Russia and North Africa.

Chart Two

Source: US Department of Energy

Chart Three

Source: US Department of Energy

Charts Two and Three depict the top 10 destinations of US LNG exports. In January 2020, the US reached a new record high of exported 74 LNG cargoes with a total 8.1 Bcf/d. Both in Q1 2020 and Q2 202O, South Korea received the lion share of exported volume (17%), followed by the UK and Spain with a share of 16% and 15%, respectively. However, COVID-19 mitigation efforts and a mild weather drove global demand for natural gas to drastically contract ‒ leading to cancellation of many cargoes. 

Rise of trading

The industry relies on different indicators to measure and track market liquidity over time. Churn rate is considered as a key metric to determine if a hub is commercially successful and vibrant. This rate is defined as the ratio of trading volume to physical volume consumed. In essence, the churn rate is an indicative of the number of times a unit of natural gas is traded and re-traded before it is finally consumed. As shown in Chart Four, the churn ratio of Henry Hub reached a maximum of 51 in the second quarter of 2020, which is significantly higher than the threshold of ten2 that has been established by the industry to classify a market as mature. This ratio has fluctuated between 36 and 51 in recent years. This strong level indicates the robustness and commercial relevance of the contract as a benchmark.

Chart Four

Source: CME Group, EIA

Conclusion

As the global LNG trade transitions from procurement-based deals to an actively traded market, liquidity will continue to be a prerequisite for balancing arbitrage interconnections across different regions. The growing liquidity of Henry Hub futures during non-US trading hours is another empirical sign of how the contract is creating around the clock multimarket linkages and has become a global benchmark.

Discover Henry Hub

References

  1. ETH: 12 a.m. – 7 a.m. Central Time (CT), Monday through Friday on regular business days RTH: 7 a.m. – 4 p.m. CT, Monday through Friday on regular business days ATH: 4 p.m. – 12 a.m. CT, Monday through Friday on regular business days and at all times on weekends.
  2. According to Heather and Petrovich (2017) in an Oxford Institute for Energy Studies paper: “Commodity markets are deemed to have reached maturity when the churn is in excess of 10 times. In this one metric all others are, necessarily, reflected: if there are many participants, trading many different products in large quantities, then the churn rate is likely to be high. The churn rate is used by traders as a ‘snapshot’ of a market’s liquidity; some traders will not participate in markets with a churn of less than 10 and many financial players will only participate when the churn is above 12 times.”

About CME Group

As the world's leading and most diverse derivatives marketplace, CME Group is where the world comes to manage risk. Comprised of four exchanges - CME, CBOT, NYMEX and COMEX - we offer the widest range of global benchmark products across all major asset classes, helping businesses everywhere mitigate the myriad of risks they face in today's uncertain global economy.

Follow us for global economic and financial news.

CME Group on Twitter

CME Group on Facebook

CME Group on LinkedIn

Chart of the Month Series

Every month, CME publishes exclusive insight from gas market analysts at Timera Energy. Each chart looks at a lesser known aspect of the global natural gas markets. If you are a gas trader looking for an edge, sign up to download the latest chart.

Sign Up