GEORGE E. WARREN CORPORATION
NYMEX RULE VIOLATION:
EXCHANGE RULE 538. EXCHANGE FOR RELATED POSITIONS
The following transactions shall be permitted by arrangement between parties in accordance with the requirements of this rule: Exchange for Physical (“EFP”) – A privately negotiated and simultaneous exchange of an Exchange futures position for a corresponding cash position. Exchange for Risk (“EFR”) – A privately negotiated and simultaneous exchange of an Exchange futures position for a corresponding OTC swap or other OTC instrument. Exchange of Options for Options (“EOO”) – A privately negotiated and simultaneous exchange of an Exchange option position for a corresponding OTC option position or other OTC instrument with similar characteristics. For purposes of this rule, an EFP, EFR or EOO shall be referred to as an Exchange for Related Position (“EFRP”).
C. Related Position
The related position component of an EFRP must be the cash commodity underlying the Exchange contract or a by-product, a related product or an OTC derivative of such commodity underlying the Exchange contract or a by-product, a related product or an OTC derivative instrument of such commodity that has reasonable degree of price correlation to the commodity underlying the Exchange contract. The related position component of an EFRP may not be a futures contract or an option on a futures contract. Each EFRP requires a bona fide transfer of ownership of the underlying asset between the parties or a bona fide, legally binding contract between the parties consistent with relevant market conventions for the particular related position transaction.
The execution of an EFRP transaction may not be contingent upon the execution of another EFRP or related position transaction between the parties where the transaction result in the offset of the related position without the incurrence of market risk that is material in the context of the related position transactions.
Pursuant to an offer of settlement George E. Warren Corporation (“GE Warren”) presented at a hearing on October 30, 2018, in which GE Warren neither admitted nor denied the findings or the rule violation upon which the penalty is based, a Panel of the NYMEX Business Conduct Committee (“Panel”) found that, on February 1, 2018, GE Warren executed two Exchange for Physical (“EFP”) transactions. In the first EFP, GE Warren sold one February 2018 NY Harbor ULSD (“FEB18 HO”) futures contract to its counterparty at a price of $2.0692. In the second, GE Warren purchased one March 2018 NY Harbor ULSD (“MAR18 HO”) futures contract from the same counterparty, at the same price, $2.0692.
The transactions were contingent upon each other and were executed in manner to avoid any material market risk associated with the EFP’s related position components.
The Panel found that, as a result, GE Warren violated Exchange Rule 538.C. (EFRP – Related Position).
In accordance with the settlement offer, the Panel ordered GE Warren to pay a fine to the Exchange in the amount of $20,000.