| Notice to Members |
| Notice No. 93 03/04/2005 |
| Amendments to NYMEX Rule 6.41 Regarding Crosstrades and Temporary Affiliations |
|---|
| The Executive Committee and Board of Directors, at their respective meetings on March 1 and 2, 2005, reviewed and approved amendments to NYMEX Rule 6.41, Trading Standards for Floor Brokers, regarding Broker Associations. The amendments, effective March 7, 2005, define temporary affiliations on the NYMEX Division consistent with the way they are defined and treated on the COMEX Division. Members who are affiliated with one another may not, on either Division, execute customer orders opposite one another. On the COMEX Division, temporarily affiliated brokers must denote on their trading cards the time during which they are affiliated. As a matter of practice, they may trade with one another after the temporary affiliation is marked as having ended, provided that they do not use or disclose information regarding resting orders they became aware of by virtue of the temporary affiliation. As NYMEX Division rules do not currently provide for a similar marking of trading cards, the relevant provisions of NYMEX Rule 6.41 have been amended to be consistent with COMEX Rule 104.24, Crossing of Orders.
(Bold and Underlined indicate additions, strikethroughs indicate deletions.) (A) No Trading Member shall purchase any commodity for future delivery, purchase any call option, or sell any put option for any commodity options contract, for his own account, or for any account in which he has an interest, while holding an order of another person for the purchase of any future, any call option, or sale of any put option, in the same commodity which is executable at the market price or at the price at which such transaction can be made for the Member's own account or the account in which he has an interest. (B) No Trading Member shall sell any commodity for future delivery, sell any call option or purchase any put option for his own account, or for any account in which he has an interest, while holding an order of another person for the sale of any future, any call option, or purchase of any put option, in the same commodity which is executable at the market price or at the price at which such transaction can be made for the Member's own account or the account in which he has an interest. (C) No Trading Member shall execute any transaction or place an order in NYMEX ACCESS® for any account of another person for which buying or selling orders can be placed or originated or for which transactions can be executed by such member, without the prior specific consent of such other person (hereinafter referred as to "discretionary orders") regardless of whether the general authorization for such orders or transactions is pursuant to a written agreement, except that discretionary orders may be placed with another Member for execution. Within the meaning of this subparagraph, an order which gives the Trading Member discretion only with respect to time and price shall not be deemed to be a discretionary order. The restrictions set forth in this subparagraph shall not apply to discretionary orders for: (i) member of the Trading Member's immediate family, which is defined to mean a spouse, parent, parent of a spouse, brother, sister, child, or spouse of a child; (ii) a member of the Exchange; (iii) a proprietary account of the Trading Member as that term is defined in CFTC Rule 1.3(y); or (iv) a non-member account provided the Member does not trade for his personal account or any other customer account. However, a Trading Member shall withhold on the Exchange Trading Floor any order belonging to members of his immediate family, other members, or proprietary accounts until after the execution of executable orders for the accounts of other persons. (D) No Trading Member shall disclose at any time that he is holding an order of another person or shall divulge any order revealed to him by reason of his relationship to such other person, except to execute an order or at the request of an authorized representative of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission or the Exchange. (E) No Floor Member on the Floor having an order from another person may take the opposite side of the transaction for himself, directly or indirectly, or for an account of: i) any firm, corporation or other entity of which he is a partner, officer, employee, or otherwise a member of a broker association; or ii) any partner, officer, employee or broker association member of an entity listed in subparagraph (i) of this Rule, nor may he execute a trade on behalf of a customer opposite any broker with whom he is affiliated. For purposes of this Rule, any two persons having the following relationship shall be deemed to be affiliated: (1) partners; (2) employees of the same employer; (3) an employer and his employee; (4) any two members temporarily acting in any of the foregoing capacities; (5) officers, directors and 10% shareholders of the same corporation; and (6) members of a broker association, as defined in Rule 6.43A. (7) Temporarily Affiliated Members. (a) In addition to the other circumstances set forth in (E) above, floor members shall be deemed to be temporarily affiliated and, therefore, subject to the cross-trade prohibition set forth in section (E) of this Rule whenever one floor member assists another floor member with the execution of customer orders for a limited period of time. Such assistance may encompass, but is not limited to, arrangements by which one floor member substitutes for another floor member absent from the ring or who handles overflow customer orders for another floor member who is too busy to handle his customer orders by himself. (b) Whenever one floor member executes customer orders for another member on a temporary basis, the floor member shall delineate the period of time during which he is assisting the other floor member by drawing a line on his trading card at the point in time he begins to perform services for the other member and at the point in time he ends handling the other floor member's customer orders. (c) A floor member shall not use or disclose to any other person information regarding another floor member's customer orders which he has obtained in connection with or as the result of a temporary affiliation with the other floor member. (F) (1) NYMEX Brent Crude Oil Futures. The provisions of Section (E) above shall not be applicable to trading in NYMEX Brent futures, nor in options based thereon, by a floor member or NYMEX Europe Permit Holder, trading on the NYMEX Europe floor, with the customer's prior written consent, provided the floor member or NYMEX Europe Permit Holder has bid and offered in accordance with Rule 6.40. (2) Any member of a broker association who is registered in accordance with the provisions of Rule 6.43A may apply for an exemption from the prohibitions set forth in paragraph (E) this Rule on the grounds that the activity for which registration as a broker association has been required does not occur on a daily basis. Exemptions shall be determined on a case by case basis. If the exemption is granted, the Floor Member will only be prohibited from taking the opposite side of a transaction as proscribed in paragraph (E) during those trading sessions that he is engaging in the activity for which registration as a broker association has been required. Any request for an exemption from the prohibitions of this Rule shall be filed with the President or his designee on a form to be prescribed by the Exchange. A written determination shall then be issued in response to the request for exemption. (G) No Floor Member on the Floor holding a customer order that was given to him by another floor broker, or having had actual disclosure of a customer order from another floor broker, may use the details of the customer order at any time to take unfair advantage in a transaction for himself, directly or indirectly, or for an account of: i) any firm, corporation or other entity of which he is a partner, officer, employee, or otherwise a member of a broker association; or ii) any partner, officer, employee or broker association member of an entity listed in subparagraph (i) of this Rule. (H) No Floor Member shall withhold or withdraw from the market any order or part of an order for the convenience of another. |
| Should you have any questions or require any further information, please contact exchangeinfo@nymex.com |